Broadkite

Quarantine early: how we protect shared warmup pools

Complaints, bounces and tampering take a mailbox out of a shared warmup pool early. Spam placement only slows it down. The bands, the floors and re-entry.

On this page
  1. Two kinds of problem, two kinds of response
  2. The bands, and why each line sits where it does
  3. Separate signals, not one blended score
  4. Good engagement does not cancel a complaint
  5. Nothing fires on one bad day
  6. Tampering, and what it is not
  7. Re-entry is not a timer
  8. The one idea to keep

A shared warmup pool has to act on a bad mailbox before the mailbox providers do. Broadkite quarantines a mailbox, out of the pool for 7 days with its campaigns paused, at 0.10% spam complaints, 5% bounces or repeated tampering with warmup mail it received. Spam placement is handled differently: it never removes a mailbox, it slows it down, because warming is how placement recovers. Here is where each line sits and why.

Two kinds of problem, two kinds of response

A warmup pool works by having mailboxes write to each other and reply, so providers see ordinary two-way mail. Anything one mailbox does affects the partners it writes to. That makes two very different failures look alike at first:

  • Things a mailbox does to other people. Recipients reporting its mail as spam, a list that bounces, an owner deleting or spam-flagging warmup mail from partners. These cost everyone else in the pool, and they act early.
  • A reading of its own reputation. Its warmup mail landing in spam at Gmail, Outlook or Yahoo. That hurts the mailbox itself, and the cure is more of the slow, clean sending the pool provides.

Treating the second like the first would push a struggling mailbox out of the one place it can recover.

The bands, and why each line sits where it does

Band Trigger What happens
Watch 10% spam placement at Gmail, Outlook and Yahoo, or 0.03% complaints Warmup volume down, spacing up, closer monitoring
Throttled 20% spam placement at Gmail, Outlook and Yahoo Warmup and campaigns at half volume, lifted when placement recovers
Quarantine 0.10% complaints, 5% bounces, or repeated tampering with received warmup mail Out of the shared pool for 7 days, campaigns paused
Block 0.30% complaints, 10% bounces, or clear abuse Out of the shared pool for 30 days

The complaint and bounce lines are anchored to the points where providers act. Google’s sender guidelines ask senders to keep reported spam below 0.10% and never reach 0.30%. Amazon SES documents account reviews around a 0.1% complaint rate and a 5% bounce rate. Quarantine fires at the first of those lines and block at the second, so a mailbox leaves the pool while its reputation can still recover. The enforcement numbers, provider by provider are worth reading alongside this.

Placement is read only at the three providers whose filters judge sender reputation. A small host that junks half of what it receives runs its own filter, and its spam folder says nothing about the sender.

Separate signals, not one blended score

Each band reads one signal on its own, because each failure has its own fix. A bounce problem is a list problem: verify the list. A complaint problem is a targeting or content problem: fix who you write to and what you say. A placement problem is reputation or authentication: check SPF, DKIM and DMARC, then keep warming at lower volume.

A blended score hides which one you have, and the wrong repair can make things worse. Re-warming a mailbox whose real problem is a scraped list burns it again at a lower volume.

Good engagement does not cancel a complaint

Opens and replies are a weak positive signal, and the bands treat them that way. A mailbox with healthy engagement and a rising complaint rate still moves to quarantine, because the people pressing “report spam” are not the ones replying. Opens are a poor guide anyway: Apple Mail loads images before anyone reads, so a mailbox landing in spam can still post a healthy open rate.

Nothing fires on one bad day

A band only triggers on enough data to mean something. Placement needs at least 20 verified warmup deliveries at Gmail, Outlook and Yahoo over 7 days, so one message in spam on a Tuesday changes nothing. Complaint rates need a larger floor, around 100 delivered messages over 30 days, before they are worth acting on.

A band a mailbox is already in also lifts only once the signal falls well below the line that set it, so a mailbox hovering near a threshold is not flipped in and out every day.

Tampering, and what it is not

Every warmup message carries a verification token that is single-use and bound to its recipient, so it cannot be replayed or redirected to inflate anyone’s numbers. A token arriving somewhere it does not belong is never held against the mailbox that received it: that mailbox did not put it there.

What does count is what only a mailbox’s owner can do to warmup mail it received. Deleting a message within hours of its arrival, after a search confirms it really is in the trash, is a strike. A move to spam counts only when the evidence points to the owner rather than the provider’s own filter. One strike in a week earns a warning, two a quarantine, four a block.

Re-entry is not a timer

A quarantine holds until its end date whatever a fresh reading says, and the standing follows the address, so disconnecting and reconnecting a mailbox does not reset it. When the term ends, the mailbox requalifies on the evidence: authentication intact, no new complaint or bounce spike, no recent tampering, and placement back under 10% on a fresh sample, starting again from low volume. The full sequence is in our reputation recovery playbook.

The one idea to keep

Act early on what a mailbox does to others, and be patient with what is happening to it. Complaints and bounces at the provider’s line take a mailbox out of the pool for a week. Spam placement slows it down and lets it warm back up. The warmup and deliverability pages show how the pool and health tracking fit together, and the cold email guide puts all of it in order.

Was this post helpful?

Okay

What helped most?

Keep reading

Send your next campaign from Broadkite

Find leads, write the sequence and send from mailboxes you own, warmed and paced for you. Or ask Claude to draft it.